Recommended by the New York Times, Wine Spectator, Food & Wine, and Many More. Check out our recent press.

Award-winning SF wine shop – free local delivery & fast nationwide shipping. Learn more

EXTRA BRUT WINE CLUB SEPTEMBER 2026

Dear Extra Brut Friends

We all know Champagne is, in large part, Pinot country. Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier together make up about 70% of all the vines planted in Champagne. Even Chardonnay is a cross between Pinot and an ancient grape, Gouais Blanc.

But there’s another Pinot in Champagne, one we almost never see and talk about even less: Pinot Blanc. Pinot Blanc (like Pinot Meunier) is a natural mutation of Pinot Noir. In fact, genetically speaking, it is practically identical to Pinot Noir – it’s just lost the genes that color Pinot Noir’s skins. Hence, Pinot Blanc.

Now you might think that a naturally white variant of Pinot Noir would be perfect for Champagne, a region specializing in white sparkling wines made from Pinot Noir. And the growers used to think so too! Pinot Blanc was widely planted before phylloxera. But when Champagne was being replanted in the 1930s, the newly created appellation forbade new plantings of Pinot Blanc. It was lower yielding than the big three grapes, and more susceptible to disease and frost damage. So even where it was grandfathered in, the grape nearly disappeared.

Today we have more respect for genetic diversity and, although still extremely rare, there’s a burgeoning respect for Pinot Blanc in Champagne. There are even a few very culty Pinot Blanc cuvees (Bolorée from Cedric Bouchard (Roses de Jeanne) probably the cultiest).  But the grape is still incredibly rare and single varietal examples are rarer still. 

Which makes this month’s wine club such a special treat. We have been able to pair a 100% Pinot Blanc made in the purest fashion with a 100% Pinot Noir from a grower who gives us the most precise expression of the grape from its heartland in the Montagne de Reims.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 1

Our thoughts on this selection

It’s hard to find a purer expression of Pinot Noir than Autour de la Creusette. Most Champagne is blended, and Pinot Noir is included for body, structure, deep fruit, and ageability. Classic blends add Chardonnay for lift and focus, and Meunier for more accessible fruit. Together, they make a complete wine.

But grown in the right terroir and handled by an attentive grower, Pinot Noir on its own makes a wine that isn’t just complete, but one that also tells a beautiful story. Bertrand-Delespierre is one such grower. 

Didier Bertrand and Chantal Delespierre established the domaine in 1980, on the Petite Montagne de Reims. The soils here are varied with clay, sand, and marl layered over a deeper subsoil of chalky limestone. Pinot Noir here develops striking depth, as well as a vibrant chalky minerality – especially if the vines have had time to dig through all those layers, deep into the limestone subsoil.

Autour de la Creusette is made from Pinot Noir growing in clay-and-silt soils on vines planted in 1973 and 1980. This is old vine Pinot from the heart of the Petite Montagne and the vines have dug deep into those soils. Didier and Chantal’s children, Adrien and Clémence, make the wines today. They’ve continued their parents’ work, farming without herbicides and working with enormous precision in the cellar. 

They vinify just over a third of this cuvee in demi-muids (600L barrels) with the remainder in stainless-steel tank. Using two vessels (one that breathes through pores in the oak, the other completely sealed) allows the wine to develop different textures and components. They block malo, and add only a tiny 1 g/L of dosage, keeping the acidity bright and letting the richness of the Pinot Noir fruit speak for itself. 

This is a tiny production wine: fewer than 200 cases in this vintage. The family has to work on that scale to produce a portrait of a single site with such specificity. But it pays off for us. The wine is delicious and amazing food (Eating Karaage? Try this!), a brilliant expression of the terroir, and (key to our project this month) also a quintessential example of what makes Pinot Noir great in Champagne. 

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 2

Our thoughts on this selection

Pinot baseline set with our Pinot Noir, we move on to the Pinot Blanc. 

The Demets family is based in southern Côte des Bar. This is the part of Champagne furthest from Reims and Epernay and closest to Chablis. And the soils are more like Chablis (lots of the classic Kimmeridgian and Portlandian clay-limestone marl) than like Champagne’s more famous chalk-dominant terroir. 

Pierre Demets, grandson of the founder, joined the domaine in 2008 and took over six years later. Today, he and his wife, Mathilde, farm their ten hectares organically and have focused intently on their terroir and their biodiversity. Their tiny plot of Pinot Blanc, planted in 1992, had always been used as a small component of their blended Champagnes. But as Pierre and Mathilde focused more and more on biodiversity and their micro terroirs, they started to see the Pinot Blanc differently. 

It’s planted in a single parcel, Frion, with southwest exposure and the Côte des Bar typical clay-limestone soils. The exposure means afternoon sunshine for the vines, encouraging ripening. The clay in the soils gives the wine depth and (since the clay can hold water) helps with even ripening. The limestone does its usual magic, helping the fruit to find a vibrant structure and minerality. 

But here, we get a unique expression of that classic Côte des Bar terroir in the very specific voice of Pinot Blanc. The wine has subtle aromatics of white flowers and orchard fruit. And in the mouth it has classic Champagne freshness, but also a gentle, yellow-fruited timbre followed here by a mineral, saline finish.

It’s a blanc de blancs, but it’s nothing like a 100% Chardonnay wine from the region. It has a depth that makes us think of Pinot Noir a little more, but it has a charm that is very much its own. Pierre and Mathilde gave it the merest half gram of dosage, and yet it has a feeling of juiciness and generosity. Combined with the salty finish, it makes us want another sip, and then another. It’s easygoing enough to savor on its own as an aperitif (especially if you’re geeking out over the Pinot Blanc’s tells). But there’s power on the finish that really makes it shine with roasted pork chops served with softened onion. 

In Closing

There’s something particularly satisfying about getting to know an unfamiliar grape through the lenses of a grape and a terroir we already love. The Bertrand-Delespierre reminds us how much Pinot Noir can do on its own – in the right spot and in the right hands. But the Demets’ Singularité helps us not only to understand the Pinot family better, but also to hear the terroir of the Côte des Bars in a new voice.

If you taste them together you’ll probably want two glasses. Go back and forth and you may see differences of terroir and grape; differences in the character of the fruit and the feeling of the wines; differences in the length and aromas and the complexity. But you will also find elements in common. Some of them will be because both wines are Pinots.

But some because both wines are Champagne.