Recommended by the New York Times, Wine Spectator, Food & Wine, and Many More. Check out our recent press.

Award-winning SF wine shop – free local delivery & fast nationwide shipping. Learn more

EXTRA BRUT WINE CLUB January 2026

When it comes to the “natural wine” movement, there is so much to say and so many questions to ask. The simple include: Are the wines too funky? Are they more “alive”? Are they more “pure”? To put a more technical gloss on the issue, you might ask: does omitting sulfur make the wines more “honest,” and enhance the expression of terroir? Or does the sulfur actually “protect” the expression of terroir – for instance, from the effects of shipping the wine?  

Of course, all this is a debate that is far from settled. We do know that natural wines became very trendy, and the market responded by flooding wine store shelves with wines that were often too funky, too cloudy or too wild. But that is just the natural evolution of things. And there remain tons of absolutely delicious natural wines that we love to drink. 

The natural wine movement has also come to Champagne. Here, the movement means, roughly, producing wines that are “zero-zero.” This means that there is no dosage, and no sulphur. Obviously, zero-zero Champagne-making can go wrong, and we have tasted more than our fair share of Champagnes that end up tasting kind of like cider. 

But we felt that this January – a month in which many of us like to back off of the excesses of the holiday season – it’s a great opportunity to show you two examples of zero zero that are truly delicious.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 1

Our thoughts on this selection

In the world of organic Champagne, the name Beaufort is royalty. Amaury’s grandfather, Jacques Beaufort, was allergic to synthetic sprays, so he converted his family estate to organic farming in 1971—decades before it was cool. Amaury grew up in the vines, learning that great wine is made in the vineyard, not the lab.

In 2018, Amaury struck out on his own, establishing his own cellar in the Aube (the southern region of Champagne closer to Chablis). He naturally applied the family’s farming philosophy but refined it.

Today’s wine is 100% Pinot Noir from the village of Polisy. Amaury vinifies it like fine Burgundy—in large wooden foudres and old barrels. He adds no sulfur and no dosage: that’s what makes this zero zero. If you are expecting something wild, prepare to be surprised by how classic this tastes. It is broad, vinous, and powerful. You get the deep, red-fruited richness of the Pinot Noir (wild cherry, currant) backed by a savory, salty structure that comes from the Kimmeridgian limestone soils. It is a wine of "controlled oxidation"—meaning it has seen air in the barrel, which gives it a nutty, complex depth, but it remains incredibly fresh and upright.

This is a wine for the dinner table. Give it some air (but not so much that you’ll lose the bubbles!), use a large white wine glass, and serve it not too cold. Champagne like this can go with a great variety of foods, but if we have to pick a couple we’ll go with roasted pork loin or a mushroom galette.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 2

Our thoughts on this selection

While Amaury Beaufort was born into natural wine, Fabian Daviaux had to stage a coup to get there.

Chavost is a cooperative in the village of Chavot-Courcourt, just south of Epernay. For decades, it was a standard operation: farmers brought in conventional grapes, and the co-op made standard, safe wine.

Then, in 2019, young Fabian took over. He convinced a group of the growers to set aside 5 hectares of organic land and let him try something radical: a line of wines with zero added sulfur. This is unheard of for a co-op, which usually prizes consistency above all else.

While Beaufort uses oak barrels to build texture, Chavost is all about stainless steel. Fabian wants to capture the pure, unadulterated fruit of the grape. This "Blanc d'Assemblage" is a blend of Chardonnay (about 50%) and Pinot Meunier (about 50%). Because it is made without sulfur but in a hyper-clean, temperature-controlled environment, the fruit is explosive. It bursts with green apple, fresh pear, and a distinct chalky minerality. It is "juicy" and "alive" in a way that standard Champagne never is. It is not funky; it is high-definition.

This is your "apéro" bottle. It is zippy, salty, and energetic. It cuts right through the richness of fried foods—try it with tempura, frites, or a soft, triple-cream cheese like Brillat-Savarin. Or just drink it on its own while the Beaufort is getting some air.

Are these wines funky? We don’t think you’ll see them that away. Are they austere? Maybe compared to some of the more luxurious Champagne bottlings that you enjoyed in December.

Are they more honest, purer or more alive than they would be with a touch of sulfur? We haven’t done the double-blind experiment to say for sure. But we hope you’ll agree that they are wines that deliver tons of pleasure – the kind that derives from energy, even electricity, rather than the sweetness of dosage. We are thrilled to live in a world where we have both options to choose from.