Recommended by the New York Times, Wine Spectator, Food & Wine, and Many More. Check out our recent press.

Award-winning SF wine shop – free local delivery & fast nationwide shipping. Learn more

EXTRA BRUT WINE CLUB JUNE 2026

What Should a Bottle of Champagne Capture?

Two good answers, two great wines…

Dear Extra Brut Friends,

Every Champagne producer has to answer one question before anything else: what should this bottle capture? Should it express a place across time, blending years together to smooth out nature's mood swings and get at something permanent? Or should it share the specifics of a single harvest, the truth of those vines in that year?

You might think you know how the answers break down. Blending vintages to make non-vintage is the art of the grandes marques, with their cellar masters and oceans of reserve wine. The Growers, on the other hand, are where we look for the art of the specific: not just single-vintage Champagnes, but also single vineyard and single-variety  

This month's wines prove that schematic understanding just isn’t the whole truth.

Both wines come from small family growers. Both are Extra Brut, dosed at 4 grams per liter. Both are obsessed with letting their terroir speak. But while Julien Prelat, a fourth-generation grower in the Côte des Bar, refuses to blend anything at all, Madame Fallet, working a few hectares  in Grand Cru Avize the same way since 1957, has always blended two vintages into one wine.

So it’s not just that the greatest big houses make some rarities in the mold of a Grower Champagne, it’s that even some of the true pioneers of Grower Champagnes make mulit-vintage blends  to get at the truth of their terroir. 

Two delicious answers to the same question. We’re thrilled to share them both with you this month.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 1

Our thoughts on this selection

Blending as Tradition

There's no sign on the door. No website, no tasting room, no Instagram. If you found your way to Madame Fallet's cellar in Avize, it would be because somebody whispered it to you. Cross the threshold and you step into Champagne as it was decades ago: old foudres aging in cool natural chalk cellars, and tens of thousands of bottles resting quietly in the dark.

Madame Fallet and her late husband started bottling their own Champagne in 1957. The "grower Champagne revolution" we love to talk about was still half a century away. In 1957, nearly everyone in Avize sold their grapes to the big houses and called it a living. But not the Fallets. They just quietly did it all themselves, and kept doing it, building a following of private clients who drove to the cellar door. They were making Grower Champagne before anyone thought it would become a movement..

But this pioneering, fiercely independent little estate has always made a blended wine. Every bottling combines two consecutive vintages, roughly two-thirds from the newer harvest and one-third reserve. Old vines (50 to 80 years) on Grand Cru Avize chalk, picked late and ripe, fermented in large, old, neutral Alsatian oak casks, then aged at least seven years on the lees before disgorgement. (That's more than four times what the rules require; for a refresher on what all that time on the lees does to a Champagne, see our March booklet.)

Why blend, when your terroir is this good? Because for Madame Fallet, the blend expresses  the truth of the terroir. Any single year is weather; two years woven together gets you something closer to the nature of Avize. The reserve wine brings depth and a quiet autumnal richness, the younger wine brings lift. Blending is not a commercial compromise. It's how she paints her portrait of the place.

EXTRA BRUT PICK NO. 2

Our thoughts on this selection

Building a moment

The Prelat family has grown grapes in Celles-sur-Ource for four generations, but Julien is the first to vinify and bottle his own wine.

It wasn’t an easy transition. When Julien embarked on his journey there was no family winery. There was no cellar. There was no equipment. He sold his first vintages as still wine to a négociant  while he saved for equipment. His first Champagne released under his own name came in 2010, and it was tiny: just 6,000 bottles. Today he makes about 30,000, which is still a rounding error by grande marque standards.

There were challenges, but Julien also had advantages. He had the great terroir. And he also had very special friends. If Celles-sur-Ource rings a bell, it's probably because it’s the home village of Cedric Bouchard, Julien's neighbor, ami, and mentor. Cedric is famous, of course, for his super-collectible Roses de Jeanne Champagnes, which made "one grape, one vineyard, one vintage" into a leading Champagne philosophy.

Julien took Bouchard's lessons to heart, but applied them in his own way. Like Bouchard, he makes single-vineyard, single-varietal wines. He and his wife, Karine, farm their 7 hectares organically and by hand. But where Bouchard sought to push the envelope , Prélat seeks harmony and offers us a sense of elegant classicism. 

For instance, dosage is not a dirty word with the Prelats, even as Bouchard makes all his wines as Brut Nature. The Prelats believe that balance and harmony are everything, and that getting the dosage right makes the wine pop. So they taste each release blind at varying levels of dosage until they find the one that lets the wine truly sing. If a wine ends up showing best with no dosage or 1 g/L, that’s fine. If it is at its most expressive with 4g/L well, that’s fine too. And in the case of the base '22 Les Vignes Basses, that number was [4] g/L.

Les Vignes Basses might be the purest test of Prelat’s approach, because the grape is Meunier. Meunier has spent most of Champagne's history as the workhorse blending grape. It’s an early-ripening, frost-hardy variety the big houses use to round out their assemblages but never put in the spotlight.

Julien does the opposite with Les Vignes Basses, releasing it as a 100% Meunier cuvee from a single parcel in Celles-sur-Ource's marl and limestone. He ferments in stainless steel and blocks malolactic conversion, so the wine keeps every bit of its natural racy cut. 

2022 in the Côte des Bar is a top vintage giving wines with the ideal balance of ripeness, acidity and mineral cut. Thanks to meticulous farming and the magic of this vintage, Julien captured everything blenders prize in Meunier. But instead of weaving it into the background, he puts all that decadent complexity center stage and in sharp focus. There is apple blossom, ripe orchard fruit, a creamy texture, all framed by beautifully fresh acidity and a chalky-saline Côte des Bar finish from those famous Kimmeridgian soils. 

Which answer is right?

Neither, of course. That's the fun of it. Assemblage is as old as Champagne itself, and as Madame Fallet proves, it’s a traditional technique that belongs to tiny artisans just as much as to the great houses. Bottling a single moment is the region's newest serious idea, and in hands like Julien's it's a totally worthwhile project – and particularly easy to appreciate in a vintage like 2022. But when we compare these gorgeous Champagnes we don’t feel one is better than the other. They’re two sincere takes on what Champagne can be, both equally worthwhile and equally delicious.

Start with the Fallet. For all its years in the cellar it pours bright and precise, and it makes a brilliant aperitif: chalky, citrusy, with the toasted depth of all that lees time underneath. Oysters, crudo, or a bowl of salted almonds will do nicely. Then move to the Prelat as the meal builds. Its texture and saline grip love charcuterie, mushrooms, and roast chicken, and it rewards patience; pour it a touch warmer than you think and revisit the glass as it opens.